Saturday, May 5, 2012

Women in Clergy

This is a speech I gave on the topic of women in clergy at my temple last night.

Women in Clergy - 40th Anniversary


Last summer, as many of you know, I took a trip to Israel. Before I left, Cantor Glozman advised me any mention of my desire to go to cantorial school was likely to cause a stir. In Israel, where even the secular are Orthodox, women are rarely found fulfilling clergy roles and strong emotions and even stronger opinions surround the topic.

I was at a barbecue with a female soldier and her very large family. After a few glasses of wine and lots of conversation, my guard was down. The soldier's aunt asked me what I do for a living. I told her that I sang and taught lessons and was trying to get into graduate school. She asked me what I wanted to study. I didn't think about it – I told her I wanted to be a cantor.

She gave me a funny look and said, “A chazzan?”

“Yes...” Another long pause...

“A Jewish chazzan?”

At this point, I could tell I had waded into murky water.

“But you're a woman!” She was baffled. She pulled a few more people into the conversation, and after a bunch of laughter, some pointing, and a flurry of Hebrew that I couldn't understand, the entire family descended on me. My soldier friend translated their questions for me, which were flying at me from every direction in Hebrew.

“How can a woman be a Chazzan?”

“How will you care for your family?”

“Will the rabbi be a woman, too?”

“How can a woman give advice to men?”

“Will men go to your synagogue?”

“Isn't that against halachah?”

“Why would you want such a hard life?”

It wasn't until these questions were posed to me that I realized I was unequipped to answer them. To me, women in the clergy are as natural as men in construction. Although I was peripherally aware that women were a fairly new installment on the bimah, it has never been a part of my experience. I have Rabbi Sally Priesand to thank for that, as well as Rabbi Jody, Cantor Rachelle Nelson, and a slew of other wonderful female rabbis and cantors who have been my examples as I've delved into my Judaism over the last seven or eight years. I feel blessed to be where I am, in a place where the fact that I'm a woman will hardly be considered as I navigate through this career. I really believe that I am lucky enough to be entering the cantorate in an age where I will never be able to blame my gender for holding me back.

I'm not particularly proud of the job I did of defending the Reform Jewish way of life in the midst of my Israeli grilling. I wish that I had taken the time before I left to consider the answers to some of these questions. How can a woman be a cantor? Really, how could the cantorate, or the rabbinate, be effective WITHOUT the presence of women? It is clear, as glass ceilings break all around us every day, that women have every bit as much intellectual ability and drive as men do. We simply need the brightest, most spiritual people of both genders to ensure that the educational and pastoral needs of our communities are met, and to ensure that we are able to continue to grow in knowledge and strength as a community.

I could go on, but I think I'm preaching to the choir here. I want to note the significance of this anniversary for me. It has been 40 years since the first female rabbi was ordained. Just as Torah tells us that our ancestors wandered in the desert for 40 years, we have spent 40 years navigating this new and exciting territory of a more inclusive rabbinate and cantorate. It is my hope that the time has come for us to emerge from this desert into a new reality in which the differences and similarities in our genders are celebrated, but the conversation can move on to things that are, frankly, more interesting and more important than what amounts to our anatomy and our tendencies. I believe we have arrived there. It is such an exciting time for me to begin my studies to enter this career. For, really, the first time in history, there are no barriers for someone like me as I seek the cantorate in the Reform Movement.

Of course, there is still work to do. After the picnic, the soldier's mother pulled me aside and told me that I'm a nice girl and that she wants me to be happy, and asked if she could give me some advice. She went on to tell me that I should find another career because the road ahead of me would be too hard, I would never find a job, and, besides, a female chazzan is against halachah.

Change comes easier when someone sets a good example for others to follow. I thanked her for her advice and told her that I appreciate that she cared enough to give it to me. I look to Rabbi Jody, to Cantor Michael, to Rabbi Mitch, and to all those who have paved the way and whom we are celebrating tonight, as my examples. Perhaps, with a lot of study and growth, I can eventually be one of the examples that changes the hearts and minds of those who think that there is no place for a woman here on the bimah. Shabbat shalom.

No comments:

Post a Comment